Friday, January 17, 2020
Mysteries of A Masterpiece of Sixteenth Century Graphic Art
Art historians and dentists alike have attempted over the centuries to unravel the mystery of Renaissance artist, Ambrosius Holbeinââ¬â¢s Memento Mori Map. 1 The woodcut map was created as Holbein worked as an artist and illustrator for Sir Thomas Moreââ¬â¢s Utopia. This piece of early sixteenth century art was brought to the forefront of the masses when it was used by Peter Ackroyd in 1998. [Ackroyd P. The life of Thomas More. London: Chatto & Windus, 1998. ] The author used Holbeinââ¬â¢s Map of Utopia on the back dust cover of his book Life of Thomas More,2 thus reviving a debate that had lasted for centuries concerning the unusual illustration.Holbeinââ¬â¢s map includes an island, three sailing vessels and a land mass in the background among other objects. Upon closer inspection, the land mass is thought to be a human skull and the largest sailing vessel in the forefront is the skullââ¬â¢s teeth. This unusual ââ¬Å"discoveryâ⬠caused quite a stir both in the f ield of art and in the field of dentistry. While the masses viewed the sketch as an ââ¬Å"intellectual puzzleâ⬠, it began to draw the attention of dentists who saw the sketch as an instructional guide in dental radiology.It heightened their perception of concealed anatomical structures in the human mouth. In 1516, Thomas More commissioned a young artist, Ambrosius Holbein,3 to illustrate his upcoming book, Utopia. Little did he know that five hundred years later, art historians and dentists alike would still be arguing about the hidden meanings of the woodcut sketch Holbein had produced. The hidden skull did not become apparent to viewers until a Third Edition of Thomas Moreââ¬â¢s book [Holbein, H. Painting prints and reception. Washington: National Gallery of Art. Yale Studies in the History of Art 60.] was published. There were no illustrations in the second edition but the Third Edition contained a much more complex version of the original sketch. Art Historians continue to argue about whether Holbein could have completed the later version, since it is apparent that itââ¬â¢s was a creator much more accomplished artist. The sketch of the Third Edition contains a number of similarities to the original but is a more complex work. In the sketch of the Third Edition, the teeth of the skull become much more apparent. The ribs and planking of the ship provide the so-called ââ¬Å"teethâ⬠of the grinning skull.The lower row of rectangles is not a third row of teeth, but instead the bony root prominences of the lower incisors and premolars. In Peter Ackroydââ¬â¢s discussion4 of the sketch, he points out that the island as described in the book has the same dimensions as England, with the number of city states corresponding to the number of counties, plus London, which latter city the main town of the island resembles. These city states are reduced to six in the map. Another interesting enigma, these facts heightened the debate over Holbeinââ¬â ¢s work. Was he a clever artist who enjoyed symbolism and trickery? Or was his original work a mere accident?It becomes very clear in his second ââ¬Å"Map of Utopiaâ⬠5 that he indeed had realized the intriguing controversy his first map had instigated. In this subsequent work, he takes the drawing to a deeply detailed level not seen in the original. The island itself has been transformed, with its visual wit bringing it up to the same standard as the text it accompanies. At a time when much of book illustration was religious or classical in theme, Ambrosius Holbeinââ¬â¢s Utopia prints were distinguished by their modernity in showing living people. This fact also sets the sketch apart from others of its day. Another well-known fact adds to the controversy.Thomas More was known to be a clever sort of man who enjoyed word play. Did he originally commission Holbein to create this clever skull with ââ¬Å"teethâ⬠? Or was it merely a happy accident? Serendipity. It is intere sting to note that the Latin word for death is ââ¬Å"morsâ⬠. In 1533 Hans Holbein, Ambrosius Holbeinââ¬â¢s younger brother, also an accomplished artist, painted The Ambassadors. [Queen Anne House, 2A St. Andrews Street, Hertfordshire, SG141JA] This painting was commissioned by King Henry the Eighth of England. In this monumental painting, the king is presenting the Charter of Union to the barbers and surgeons at Bridewell Palace in 15406.In this painting, done fifteen or so years after his brotherââ¬â¢s map, Hans plays with the laws of perspective by including an enigmatic anamorphic skull in the painting. A discussion ensued over this work as well. Was it a memento mori, a reminder of mortality? In 1997, a special exhibition in the National Gallery of London6 celebrated the completion of the cleaning and restoration of the ââ¬Å"Ambassadorsâ⬠painting. The exhibition was accompanied by an explanatory publication which reignited the debate over the Ambrosius Holbei nââ¬â¢s ââ¬Å"Map of Utopiaâ⬠.7 Considerable attention was paid to the skull in the foreground of The Ambassadors, the oblique slash of which is such a challenging enigma in the composition. To illustrate how the effect was achieved, both photographic and computer regenerated skull images of Hansââ¬â¢ anamorphic skull were shown. In the years that followed Ambrosius Holbeinââ¬â¢s original and subsequent Map of Utopia, another ââ¬Å"happy accidentâ⬠occurred. The barbers and surgeons began to investigate the woodcut sketch for its value as an aid in dental radiology. Works Cited 1. Lupton J H. The Utopia of Thomas More in Latin and the English of Robynsonââ¬â¢s translation of 1551.Oxford, 1895. 2. More C. The life of Sir Thomas More. pp 190ââ¬â1. 1828. In Routh E M G Sir Thomas More and his friends. 1477ââ¬â1535. p 109. London: Oxford University Press, 1934. 3. North J. The Ambassadorââ¬â¢s secret. Holbein and the world of the Renaissance. London: H ambledon and London, 2002. 4. Ackroyd P. The life of Thomas More. London: Chatto & Windus, 1998. 5. Holbein, H. Painting prints and reception. Washington: National Gallery of Art. Yale Studies in the History of Art 60. 6. Young S. Annals of the barber surgeons. pp80ââ¬â84. London: Blades East & Blades, 1890.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.